By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
BigPaulSportsBigPaulSports
Notification Show More
Latest News
Cam Ward has a message for NFL teams: 'If you don't draft me, that's your fault'
Cam Ward has a message for NFL teams: ‘If you don’t draft me, that’s your fault’
Game Analysis NFL
Lil Wayne defends Jordan Love, talks Lakers' championship on 'First Things First'
Lil Wayne defends Jordan Love, talks Lakers’ championship on ‘First Things First’
Game Analysis
5 ways to fix NBA All-Star Weekend after widely panned 2025 event
5 ways to fix NBA All-Star Weekend after widely panned 2025 event
Game Analysis
Can Lakers make a title run as sixth-best odds to win NBA Finals? | First Things First
Can Lakers make a title run as sixth-best odds to win NBA Finals? | First Things First
Game Analysis
Bucky Brooks’ Top 5 Super Bowl contenders sparks debate | First Things First
Bucky Brooks’ Top 5 Super Bowl contenders sparks debate | First Things First
Game Analysis NFL
Aa
  • Big Paul Sports
  • Services
  • Game Analysis
  • Free Picks
  • Premium Content
  • Registration
  • Member Login
Reading: Are the Colts and Jonathan Taylor at the point of no return? Here’s everything we know
Share
Aa
BigPaulSportsBigPaulSports
  • Big Paul Sports
  • Services
  • Game Analysis
  • Free Picks
  • Premium Content
  • Registration
  • Member Login
Search
  • Big Paul Sports
  • Services
  • Game Analysis
  • Free Picks
  • Premium Content
  • Registration
  • Member Login
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
BigPaulSports > Blog > NFL > Are the Colts and Jonathan Taylor at the point of no return? Here’s everything we know
NFLSports News

Are the Colts and Jonathan Taylor at the point of no return? Here’s everything we know

BigP
Last updated: 2023/08/23 at 2:09 PM
BigP Published August 23, 2023
Share
Are the Colts and Jonathan Taylor at the point of no return? Here's everything we know
SHARE
  • Stephen Holder

    Contents
    Best of NFL NationAre the Colts serious about possibly trading him?What’s the market for Taylor?Editor’s PicksWhat are the comparisons to this situation?If there is a trade, how is Indy’s depth at running back?If there’s no trade, can the Colts salvage the relationship or will this loom all season?
    Close

    Stephen Holder

    ESPN

      Stephen joined ESPN in 2022, covering the Indianapolis Colts and NFL at large. Stephen finished first place in column writing in the 2015 Indiana Associated Press Media Editors competition, and he is a previous top-10 winner in explanatory journalism in the Associated Press Sports Editors national contest. He has chronicled the NFL since 2005, covering the Tampa Bay Buccaneers from 2005-2013 and the Colts since 2013. He has previously worked for the Miami Herald, Tampa Bay Times, Indianapolis Star and The Athletic.
  • Jeremy Fowler

    Close

    Jeremy Fowler

    senior NFL national reporter

    • ESPN staff writer
    • Previously a college football reporter for CBSSports.com
    • University of Florida graduate

Aug 22, 2023, 03:20 PM ET

INDIANAPOLIS — The monthlong saga between Jonathan Taylor and the Indianapolis Colts might be headed toward a resolution, with sources telling ESPN on Monday that Taylor has been granted permission to seek a trade partner.

The Colts are looking for significant draft-pick compensation — a first-round choice or a comparable package of picks — but the decision to allow Taylor to seek the trade marks a significant milestone in the ongoing drama between the team and the 2021 NFL rushing champion.

Best of NFL Nation

&#8226 Tony Pollard as Cowboys’ goal-line back
&#8226 The ‘Brian Flores Experience’ for Vikes
&#8226 Diving into Nick Bosa’s holdout
&#8226 Is rookie Tank Bigsby the Jags’ RB2?
&#8226 Herbert embraced leadership challenge

Taylor has been seeking a contract extension while the Colts have been adamant in their position that the timing is not right to extend Taylor. The resulting back-and-forth has led to this point, and a resolution could be close. NFL teams must finalize their roster by Aug. 29, creating something of a deadline for the Taylor talks to play out.

What’s next? What does the market for Taylor look like and is there any recent precedent for a situation like this? ESPN Colts reporter Stephen Holder and NFL insider Jeremy Fowler answer the biggest questions.

Are the Colts serious about possibly trading him?

Holder: Yes. Even though Colts owner Jim Irsay issued an adamant rejection of Taylor’s earlier trade request — “we will not trade Jonathan Taylor” — the organization always kept that option on the table. Taking the step of allowing Taylor to engage with other teams is a major shift. It could also be a recognition that a trade offers a viable solution to a problem that has lingered for nearly a month.

But the Colts aren’t going to give Taylor away, sources said. Whether they get the first-round pick (or similar package of picks) they are seeking remains to be seen, but the team still regards Taylor as an elite player and wants compensation commensurate with that assessment.


What’s the market for Taylor?

Fowler: Several league execs believe Taylor, as a talent, has a strong market. He’s a 24-year-old former rushing champion with home run ability. Those are pretty rare credentials. One exec figured Taylor will be worth a Day 2 pick. And multiple teams recently have inquired.

Editor’s Picks

2 Related

But the contract will be the bigger hurdle. Teams that want to sign Taylor to a long deal — such as five years — in the $11 million or $12 million range annually, could be a nonstarter for Taylor. Yes, the 49ers gave up multiple high picks last season for Christian McCaffrey, who is the standard-bearer for backs at $16 million per year. But the 49ers paid McCaffrey $690,000 for the prorated portion of his salary last season, plus the $11.8 million he was due in 2023 (which eventually got reworked).

Meanwhile, trading for Taylor likely requires paying a big signing bonus right now as part of the new deal. That could be a problem for some interested teams. Miami has been identified as a potential spot for Taylor, due to GM Chris Grier’s penchant for targeting star players and the Dolphins’ previous interest in Dalvin Cook. But teams aren’t quite sold yet on Miami going all-in here.


What are the comparisons to this situation?

Holder: With running backs lamenting how their position is undervalued, it’s not the best environment in which to try to land a huge haul for Taylor. But as Jeremy mentions, the most recent comparison might be the deal sending McCaffrey from the Panthers to the 49ers on Oct. 21, 2022. The circumstances were different — McCaffrey had already been given a lucrative extension by Carolina and was not requesting a trade — but the parallel is that both players are elite running backs. San Francisco gave up 2023 second-, third- and fourth-round picks and a 2024 fifth-round selection. That’s a significant package for a Panthers team that is rebuilding around rookie quarterback Bryce Young.

In a similar scenario, Los Angeles Chargers running back Austin Ekeler tried to find a trade destination because of his unhappiness with his current contract. But a lack of suitors willing to meet the Chargers’ compensation demands led to a dead end. Ekeler ultimately was given an additional $1.75 million in incentives on top of his expiring four-year, $24.5 million deal. A key difference: Ekeler is 28 while Taylor is 24.

For the record, the last time a running back was traded for a first-round pick was 2013, when the Cleveland Browns traded Trent Richardson to … the Colts. That trade did not yield the intended results as Richardson lasted just two seasons in Indianapolis, averaging 3.1 yards per carry. The Colts waived him in 2015.


If there is a trade, how is Indy’s depth at running back?

Holder: Not great. In two preseason games, Colts running backs have not produced a run of 10 yards or longer. There is an obvious lack of explosiveness without Taylor, especially considering Taylor’s breakaway speed and long runs are the trademark of his game.

The Colts are also without Taylor’s top backup, Zack Moss, who sustained a broken right arm and could miss the start of the regular season. That has left Deon Jackson on top of the depth chart, a third-year player who has averaged 3.3 yards in his career. Evan Hull has promise as a pass-catching/third-down back, but the Colts don’t currently have anyone in the backfield who defenses truly fear.


Jonathan Taylor has permission to seek a trade, but that doesn’t mean he’ll be leaving Indy anytime soon. What happens if he stays with the Colts? Zach Bolinger/Icon Sportswire

If there’s no trade, can the Colts salvage the relationship or will this loom all season?

Holder: There’s been little indication that fences can be mended, but Taylor has considerable incentive to have a productive season. He could become an unrestricted free agent in the spring, and he’ll want to enter free agency following a strong performance. He will need to be activated from the physically unable to perform list by Aug. 29 or face the possibility of missing the first four weeks of the regular season. He’s also scheduled to earn $4.304 million this season, provided he complies with his contract.

But there’s another reality: If no trade materializes, rumors will continue to swirl until the trade deadline passes on Oct. 31. The standoff between Taylor and the team has already overshadowed the team’s training camp, and the attention isn’t likely to abate anytime soon. If the Colts decide to move forward with Taylor, they do so knowing the situation could be messy.

Owner Jim Irsay, in an on-air appearance during the team’s preseason broadcast Saturday night, acknowledged as much, saying, “I know [general manager] Chris Ballard is going to work hard and get the waters as calm as they can and go forward.”

Sponsored Content

Juega en grande con cryptomonedas

You Might Also Like

Cam Ward has a message for NFL teams: ‘If you don’t draft me, that’s your fault’

Bucky Brooks’ Top 5 Super Bowl contenders sparks debate | First Things First

Top 10 2025 NFL free-agent QBs: Aaron Rodgers or Russell Wilson?

2025 NFL Draft odds: Will Titans retain the No. 1 pick?

BigP August 23, 2023
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print

Follow US

Find US on Social Medias
Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Youtube Subscribe
Telegram Follow
newsletter featurednewsletter featured

Weekly Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

    Popular News
    NC St. radio broadcaster suspended indefinitely
    NCAASports News

    NC St. radio broadcaster suspended indefinitely

    BigP BigP December 31, 2022
    ‘This year is going to be much better’: At rainy spring game, fan optimism remains for Deion, Colorado
    A 30-year-old NFL veteran’s last-ditch effort to reinvent himself … as a long-snapper
    NFL scouts pick 10 sleepers for the 2024 draft: Who is flying under the radar this summer?
    Jackrabbits rout Montana, repeat as FCS champs
    - Advertisement -
    Ad imageAd image

    Categories

    • Sports

    About US

    We offer information and tips on US Sports and evernts all over the world.
    Top Categories
    • Game Analysis
    • Free Picks
    • Services
    • Premium Content

    Subscribe US

    Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

      © Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.

      Removed from reading list

      Undo
      Welcome Back!

      Sign in to your account

      Lost your password?